Why foreigners get caught out
In fights, the person who hits hardest often ends up as the accused, even if they did not start it. Self-defence must be proved with evidence, usually CCTV, witnesses and injuries on both sides. Accepting a plea deal at the duty court gives up this defence for good.
The three requirements
1. Unlawful attack
There must be a real, current or imminent attack against a person or their rights. A verbal insult is generally not enough; a punch, a push with a threat of more or a raised bottle usually is. In the defence of a home, unlawful entry counts as an attack, and in the defence of property, the attack must be a crime that puts the property at serious and imminent risk.
2. Reasonable necessity of the means
The response must be reasonably necessary to stop the attack. Courts do not require perfect proportionality, but they compare the means of attack and defence, the circumstances and the alternatives available in the moment. Continuing to hit someone who is already on the ground is no longer defence.
3. No sufficient provocation
The person defending themselves must not have provoked the attack sufficiently, for example by starting the argument with a serious insult or a push.
Defending others
Self-defence also covers the defence of another person: stepping in to protect a friend who is being attacked. The same three requirements apply.
Incomplete self-defence
When the attack existed but the response went beyond what was necessary, or there was some provocation, the court can apply incomplete self-defence. The penalty is then reduced by one or two degrees, which can turn a prison sentence into a fine or a suspended sentence.
Mutual fights
When two people or groups agree to fight, courts generally reject self-defence, because there is no unlawful attack, only a mutual exchange. Both sides may be convicted. Establishing who started and whether the fight was really mutual is key.
How self-defence is proved
- CCTV from bars, shops and streets, requested immediately.
- Independent witnesses, such as door staff or passers-by.
- Medical reports of your own injuries.
- Consistent statements, prepared with your lawyer.
A practical example
An Irish tourist punched a man who had grabbed his girlfriend and raised a glass towards her in a bar in Playa de Palma. The man needed stitches. With the CCTV and the girlfriend's statement, the court accepted complete self-defence in defence of another person and acquitted him. Read assault charges. More information on the firm's main website: assault (lesiones) (in Spanish).
Before you sign or say anything, call a lawyer
In a Spanish criminal case, what happens in the first hours shapes everything else. Call or WhatsApp us and an English-speaking criminal lawyer will tell you, in confidence, what to do next.
Questions about self-defence in Spain
Is self-defence legal in Spain?
Yes. It exempts you from liability if there was an unlawful attack, a reasonably necessary response and no sufficient provocation.
Can I defend a friend who is being attacked?
Yes. Self-defence covers the defence of other people under the same requirements.
What if I hit back too hard?
The court may apply incomplete self-defence, which reduces the penalty by one or two degrees.
Does self-defence apply in a mutual fight?
Generally not, because there is no unlawful attack, only a fight both sides accepted.